Connect with us

News

UPDATED: Appeal Court affirms Amaewhule as Speaker, voids Rivers 2024 budget

Published

on

 

 

The Court of Appeal, Abuja division, on Thursday, affirmed Martin Amaewhule as the recognised Speaker of the Rivers State House of Assembly.

A three-member panel of the Court of Appeal, in a unanimous judgment, dismissed the appeal filed by the Rivers State governor, Siminalayi Fubara, for lacking in merit.

The appellate court firmly upheld the January 22 judgment of the Federal High Court, delivered by Justice James Omotosho, which nullified the 2024 N800 million Rivers State budget of renewed hope on the grounds that it was not presented before members of the State Assembly as required by law. The court admonished Governor Fubara for not adhering to the rule of law in his actions.

 

The court held that Governor Fubara’s decision to present the 2024 Rivers State Appropriation Bill to only four out of 31 members of the Assembly constituted a gross violation of the 1999 Constitution, as amended.

 

The appellate court also determined that the withdrawal of the counter-affidavit Fubara initially filed to challenge a suit instituted by the Amaewhule-led lawmakers to be recognised as valid members of the Rivers State House of Assembly indicated his agreement with the claims filed against him.

 

Justice Joseph Oyewole, while delivering the lead judgement held that Fubara, having withdrawn all processes filed to counter the case before the trial court, cannot claim to be dissatisfied with the judgment delivered.

 

Justice Oyewole said by his coming to the appellate court, he was being inconsistent, approbating and reprobating, blowing hot and cold at the same time.

 

He said such conduct had no basis in law as parties must be consistent in their approach to court matters.

See also  BREAKING: Appeal Court affirms Amaewhule as Speaker, voids Rivers 2024 budget

 

The court held that his withdrawal from the Federal High Court case was a self-inflicted mistake that cannot be redeemed.

 

The court declared that his appeal has no utilitarian value as it cannot confer any advantage on him having lost his legal rights at the trial Court by accepting all the claims filed against him with his withdrawal from the suit.

 

Justice Oyewole said “that the person with the right to appeal is the person aggrieved by the decision that is the person to whom a decision has been pronounced against.

 

“Now the position of the appellant is further made obtainable by his position and trend the record of appeal shows on pages 1209 and 1210 that learned counsel for the appellant Mr Imafidon, withdrew all the processes filed by the appellant to contest the action and thereby conceded reaction.

 

“It is the law that a party must be consistent in the presentation of his case and cannot approbate and reprobate by chasing his disposition Willy Lilly in the course of litigation exercise.

“A party cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time, the appellant cannot seek for one thing at the lower Court and be seeking for another incongruent and parallel thing in this Court. Can the law permit him to blow hot and cold at the same time?

 

“The challenges faced by the appellant in this appeal are self-inflicted and try as one may, it is impossible to see the utilitarian value to be achieved by filing this appeal after withdrawing all processes contesting the action at the lower Court and thereby conceding the action. It seems to be purely academic for a party to concede to an action at the lower Court and then turn around to challenge the same action without any indication of fraud in the presentation of the earlier concession.”

See also  Kaduna shuts two Islamic schools after 50-year-old teacher impregnates 12-year-old girl

 

The court ordered Fubara to re-present the budget of the State to the House under the recognised Speaker (Amawhuele) as contained in Justice Omotosho’s judgement.

 

The court also stopped him from withholding the House of Assembly fund and removing the Clerk and Deputy Clerk from the House.

 

Justice Oyewole proceeded to dismiss his appeal, saying, “In a constitutional democracy the foundation of every act must be located in the Constitution. Autocracy is out of place in the constitutional democracy. I therefore resolve this issue against the appellant and in favour of the 1st and 2nd respondent.

 

“In totality, therefore, this appeal is bereft of merit and it is accordingly dismissed. The judgement of the lower Court is hereby affirmed. N500,000 cost is awarded in favour of each of the 1st to 12th respondents respectively and against the appellant.”

 

Justice Okon Abang, in agreement with Justice Oyewole’s decision, held that the appellant cannot appeal the decision of the trial Court since he did not counter it and it translates to mean that he has accepted it to be true and the Court of law can act on it.

 

He further admonished the governor for frustrating Amaewhule from carrying out his duties adding that he is using his executive powers to act in might which is not acceptable in a democratic setting

See also  UPDATED: Sultan announces end of Ramadan fasting, Sunday is Eid-el-Fitr

 

He said, “The appellant the governor of Rivers State treated the Court order with disdain, levity and subject to the discharge of his function in an unprecedented manner. I agree with the 1st and 2nd respondent counsel that these are acts of executive lawlessness.

 

“The rule of might has no place in a democratic setting. Having sworn to uphold the provisions of the constitution, the appellant was and is expected to in his relationship with the 1st and 2nd respondents, apply the rule of law, not the rule of might in matters affecting the discharge of his function as the governor of Rivers State.

 

“The appellant’s show of force and might is heavily demonstrated in the 1st and 2nd respondents’ unchallenged deposition of paragraphs 1 to 10 of the affidavit in support of the motion on notice filed by the first and second respondents.

 

“Any gathering purporting to be Rivers State House of Assembly, led by any other person other than the 2nd respondent, sits in violations of the order delivered by the trial Court dated December 7, 2023 and that person acts in vain.”

 

Recall that Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court in Abuja in his judgement upheld by the appellate Court, held that the N800 billion budget presented by Fubara to the four lawmakers was invalid as it was not properly presented before the Rivers State House of Assembly as required by the law.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Fountain Of Life Church holds Sunday service amid high security presence

Published

on

By


There was a huge outpouring excitement as members of the Fountain of Life Church came enmasse for Sunday service amit very tight security, with several police vehicles seen parked outside of the church premises in Ilupeju, Lagos.

There have been reports suggesting that the church has been sealed by the police, but reports on the ground show on Sunday that the church has not been sealed.

According to TVC News, security agents claimed they merely on hand to ensure peace and order are maintained.
 

However, journalists were not allowed to film with the conventional camera inside the church.

See also  AFCON 2021: Super Eagles draw Egypt, Sudan, Guinea Bissau
Continue Reading

News

Good morning! Nigerian Newspapers Headlines: 2027: Tinubu in Ibadan, vows rapid industrialisation

Published

on

By


1. It was very much unlike the All Progressives Congress (APC) previous presidential campaign rallies in Kaduna, Uyo, Port Harcourt, Enugu, Jos, Birnin Kebbi.

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu had called for a low key stump, and a low key rally it turned out to be, all in memory of the victims of the Friday boat tragedy in Bayelsa State.

At least 24 persons, including children, were confirmed dead in the accident.

2. Opposition parties in some states have expressed outrage over the widespread destruction of their campaign billboards, alleging deliberate attempts to stifle their political activities ahead of the 2027 general elections. The parties, in separate interviews with Sunday PUNCH, also lamented the imposition of exorbitant campaign fees, denial of access to public facilities for political rallies and restrictions on the erection of billboards



3. The Senior Pastor of the Fountain of Life Church, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya, has dragged his sister and others before a Federal High Court in Lagos, challenging his purported removal from office and the decision taken by some members of the church’s Board of Trustees. Odukoya, alongside the Incorporated Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church, instituted the action against eight defendants, including Pastor Tolu Odukoya, Mr Biodun Balogun, Mr Biodun Awosika, Pastor Rotimi Okpaise, Pastor Tobi Enuha, Pastor Gbenga Onabanjo, Pastor Fred Ohiani and Pastor Akin Osinbajo.

See also  NDLEA uncovers UK-bound cocaine concealed in palm kernel oil cans, arrests kingpin in Lagos hideout

4. The North East Unity Forum (NUF) has urged former Vice President Atiku Abubakar to abandon his 2027 presidential ambition and retire from active  politics, arguing that Nigeria needs younger and more dynamic leaders. The Forum said Atiku, who is approaching 80, lacks the physical vitality, fresh ideas and moral standing required to lead the country in an increasingly complex and fast-changing world.

5. Commercial and other activities were temporarily suspended as members and non-members of the All Progressives Congress (APC) from the South-West geopolitical zone turned out in large numbers at the zonal campaign rally of the party at the ancient Mapo Hall in Ibadan South-East Local Government Area on Saturday. All the link roads to the venue of the event were closed to traffic, while the popular Oja’ba, Oritamerin and Mapo markets were shut down for the duration of the event.

6. The House of Representatives is considering a bill seeking to make the denial of conjugal rights for at least three months an additional ground for divorce in the country. The proposed amendment to the Matrimonial Causes Act, 2004, also seeks to recognise threats or infliction of grievous bodily harm, as well as emotional and psychological trauma, as grounds for seeking the dissolution of a marriage.

See also  Insecurity: State police better option now – Obasanjo

7. Bayelsa State Governor, Senator Douye Diri, has ordered an investigation into Friday’s boat mishap in Southern Ijaw Local Government Area of the state following the recovery of 23 bodies, while 24 survivors have been rescued. The governor also directed that anyone found culpable in the incident be prosecuted, saying preliminary findings indicated that the boat was overloaded, had no passenger manifest and that most of those on board were not wearing life jackets.

8. Nigeria’s Minister of Youth Development, Ayodele Olawande, has married his partner, Stella Ifeoluwa Elegbe, in a colourful ceremony in Akure, Ondo State. The white wedding, held on Saturday at the Christ Apostolic Church, Revival Centre, Akure, attracted family members, friends,  political associates and top government officials.

9. President of the Senate, Godswill Akpabio, has warned politicians against turning the 2027 general elections into a do-or-die contest, urging political leaders to rein in their supporters and avoid actions capable of triggering tension ahead of the polls. Akpabio gave the warning while reaffirming the Federal Government’s commitment to conducting free, fair and credible elections, amid growing political activities ahead of the 2027 general elections.

See also  Good Morning! Here Are Some Major News Headlines In The Newspapers Today: Cost of living: Nigerians angry with govt officials, Shettima admits

10. The leadership dispute at the Fountain of Life Church, Lagos, following the death of its founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, has brought a difficult question facing many founder-led churches into public focus: Who takes charge when the person around whom a ministry was built is no longer there?

Continue Reading

News

Jimmy Odukoya drags sister, pastors to court, says removal illegal

Published

on

By

Embattled senior pastor of the Fountain of Life Church, Jimmy Odukoya, has taken a legal action against his sister, Tolu, and some members of the church’s board of trustees over his removal as senior pastor.

The suit, marked FHC/LAG/CS/1568/2026, was filed at the federal high court in Lagos on Friday.

According to reports, respondents in the suit are Tolu Odukoya, Biodun Balogun, Biodun Awosika, Rotimi Okpaise, Tobi Enuha, Gbenga Onabanjo, Fred Ohiani and Akin Osinbajo.

The suit was instituted by the incorporated trustees of Fountain of Life Church (first claimant) and Jimmy (second claimant).

In the suit, Jimmy asked the court to rule that the resolutions of the meetings convened by the “Concerned Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church” on January 22, 2026, February 28, 2026 and on November 16, 2026, are not invalid and of no binding effect on the church.

“Whether without compliance with Article XI, Section 60(a) (c) of The Constitution of Fountain of Life of Life Church as Amended by a Special Resolution dated January 16, 2003, the Board of Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church and/or any other organ of the church can by a decision or resolution of the Board or such other organ amend, override and/or bypass a clear and express provision of The Constitution of Fountain of Life Church as Amended by a Special Resolution dated January 16, 2003,” part of the suit reads.

See also  Appeal Court upholds Oborevwori’s election as Delta governor

“Whether having regard to the provisions of Articles VII, Section 39 read together with Article VIII subsections 45(c) and (g) of The Constitution of Fountain of Life Church as Amended by a Special Resolution dated January 16, 2003, the Board of Trustees of Fountain of Life Church could by just a resolution remove the Senior Pastor without recourse to the procedure specifically highlighted by Section 39 (b) of The Constitution of Fountain of Life Church as Amended by a Special Resolution dated January 16, 2003.”

Jimmy asked the court to rule that the decisions of concerned trustees of the court are invalid, having been “done outside of the framework of, or without strict compliance with the provisions of The Constitution of Fountain of Life Church”.

The embattled senior pastor appealed to the court to restrain the respondents from taking any further action to enforce the decisions of their meetings.

“AN INJUNCTION restraining the Defendants either individually or jointly from further acting in reckless disregard for the provisions and intent of The Constitution of Fountain of Life Church as Amended by a Special Resolution dated January 16, 2003,” part of the suit reads.

See also  BREAKING: Appeal court affirms Sanwo-Olu's victory, dismisses Jandor's case

“AN INJUNCTION restraining the Defendants from doing any act or taking any other or further action with the aim of giving effect to the decisions, resolutions and/or agreements reached at their meetings of 22nd January, 2026, 28th February, 2026 and 16th November, 2026 and the contents of their letter to the 2nd Claimant dated 17/11/2026.”

Jimmy filed the suit two days after the Lagos high court restrained him from parading himself as the senior pastor of the church following a suit filed by the incorporated trustees of the church.

The claimant — incorporated trustees of the church — had sought a “pre-emptive order of injunction” restraining Jimmy from parading himself as the senior pastor and spiritual head of the church.

On Tuesday, the church’s board of trustees removed Jimmy as senior pastor, saying his appointment was contrary to the wishes of his late father, Taiwo Odukoya, founder of the church.

The board of trustees said the decision followed a careful review of the church’s constitution and late Taiwo’s recorded instructions before his death in 2023.

See also  Good Morning! Here Are Some Major News Headlines In The Newspapers Today: Cost of living: Nigerians angry with govt officials, Shettima admits

The board said it recently discovered a video recording of the late founder made in December 2021 in which Taiwo had left succession instructions.

The board said the video was not presented before Jimmy’s appointment, which it described as wrongful.

Shortly after the board’s statement, Jimmy rejected his removal, saying it was not a constitutionally valid decision of the church’s board.

He said the board members behind the statement had been instructed since March 2026 to resign “on account of their repeated and flagrant violations of the Church’s Constitution and its founding principles and objectives”.

The board, however, maintained its position, insisting that Jimmy had ceased to be the church’s senior pastor.

The board said it had resolved to entrust the church’s interim spiritual and administrative leadership to Okpaise, a pastor in the church.

Continue Reading

Trending News