Connect with us

News

Why Chicago State University shouldn’t release my academic records to Atiku–Tinubu

Published

on

 

President Bola Tinubu has intensified his legal efforts to block the Chicago State University from releasing his academic records to his rival presidential candidate during the last election, Atiku Abubakar.

After obtaining a reprieve from the District Court of Northern Illinois, Eastern Division, with the court temporarily suspending its 20 September order compelling the university to release the documents to Atiku, Mr Tinubu has now filed a more detailed objection seeking to convince the court to reverse the order outright.

Tinubu’s application, filed by his New York-based lawyer, Oluwole Afolabi, is anchored on two broad reasons.

First is that his academic records in issue are not useful in Nigerian courts as claimed by Atiku because “the Nigerian election proceedings and the Nigerian courts have explicitly been unreceptive to the discovery.”

Tinubu’s second reason is that Atiku’s request “is unduly intrusive because it allows Applicant (Atiku) to conduct a fishing expedition into Intervenor’s private, confidential, and protected educational records.”

He urged the court to set aside the previous order, saying his political opponents had previously used his illegally obtained academic records to attack him.

“The unlawful release of documents previously allowed Intervenor’s opponents to sow confusion and spread conspiracy theories,” Tinubu’s objection read in part.

It added that Atiku’s application was not anything more than “opposition research on a political opponent”.

Atiku had set off the legal battle with an application filed on 2 August requesting the court to order the Chicago State University to release Mr Tinubu’s academic records to him.

The former Nigerian vice president requested the documents in the hope of using them at the Presidential Election Petition Court in Abuja to challenge the authenticity of the certificate presented by Mr Tinubu to Nigeria’s electoral body, INEC, for the 2023 election.

He argued that among other things, a “second Chicago State University diploma has since emerged (dated June 27, 1979) that bears the name “Bola Ahmed Tinubu” but also presents with a different font, punctuation, seal, and signatures, than the June 22, 1979 diploma, among other alleged discrepancies.”

See also  Tinubu congratulates Keir Starmer, says ‘Nigeria will deepen relations with UK’

Atiku told the US court that he wanted to authenticate these documents whether a “Chicago State University diploma in the name of Bola Ahmed Tinubu dated June 22, 1979, that was submitted to the INEC before the Nigerian presidential election in February 2023 is genuine or was forged.”

On 19 September, a magistrate judge of the court, Jeffrey Gilbert, ordered the university to release the requested documents to Atiku within two days.

Mr Tinubu’s legal team swiftly approached a district judge of the court to suspend the order to enable them to file a more elaborate challenge against it.

At an emergency hearing on 21 September, the district judge, Nancy Maldonado, agreed to delay the order compelling the Chicago State University to release the academic documents of President Tinubu.

Following the approval, Tinubu, through his legal team, filed his objection on Monday.

‘Atiku barred from using my CSU records’

In the objection filed on Monday, Tinubu’s legal team argued that the magistrate judge granted Atiku’s application even though the applicant was barred from attempting to use the discovery in the foreign proceeding.

 

“That conclusion should be rejected because the discovery cannot be ‘for use’ in the foreign proceeding due to the decision of the Nigerian Election Court, and that decision shows the Nigerian courts would not be receptive to the discovery sought by the application.

“The Magistrate gave no weight to the decision of the Nigerian Election Court, which is authoritative proof of the unreceptivity of the foreign court to the discovery sought,” the objection read in part.

It added that the possibility that the Nigerian Supreme Court, where Atiku proceeded to challenge the decision of the Presidential Election Petition Court, may accept the documents was a mere speculation and not “not an indication that foreign courts might consider the discovery.”

‘Atiku’s application is fishing expedition’
In the other plank of objection, Mr Tinubu’s team argued that while Atiku’s case at the Nigerian court only touched on “a CSU diploma”, the magistrate judge “erroneously concluded” to issue an order for the release of “other educational documents.”

See also  Kogi prison break: Tunji-Ojo blames officers, says investigation ongoing

They said the court erroneously held that “a foray into other documents” was permissible because “Intervenor also submitted other educational documents in a related proceeding in Nigeria.”

The objection added: “The Magistrate erred in requiring compliance with two subpoenas that go far beyond the narrow issue of the diploma submitted to the INEC, and finding that the education records protections were overcome by Applicant’s investigatory interests.

“The Magistrate determined that the Applicant’s interest outweighed the privacy interest because the Intervenor put the diploma at issue by submitting it to the INEC.

The Magistrate also concluded the Applicant’s interests were stronger as to ‘other educational documents’ submitted in related proceedings. This second conclusion is clearly erroneous because the ‘other documents’ are not at issue in the electoral challenge, and discovery for “related proceedings” is merely another way of describing a fishing expedition.

‘I will suffer harm if CSU releases my documents to Atiku’

Tinubu argued that he stood to suffer harm in allowing discovery on issues and documents outside the diploma because his records “were illegally obtained previously and have been utilised to attack him”.

He added: “Obtaining more documents via a subpoena – particularly ones that are not part of the INEC submission by Intervenor – is both improper and nonsensical.

“The unlawful release of documents previously allowed Intervenor’s opponents to sow confusion and spread conspiracy theories. Applicant should not be permitted to conduct discovery on the discovery illegally obtained by Applicant’s allies and Intervenor’s political opponents. Discovery on discovery is rarely appropriate and is certainly not appropriate when the sole issue Applicant identified is the Intervenor’s submission of his diploma to INEC.

“Nor does the fact that Intervenor’s educational records have been spread into court records justify discovery. Section 1782 does not authorise fishing expeditions to satisfy curiosity or resolve public controversy.”

See also  BREAKING: Tinubu owes me, I never betrayed him, says Atiku

‘I’m vindicated’

In conclusion, Tinubu said the Chicago State University had already been established as the most critical by stating that he was awarded the degree as he stated.

“This point is irrelevant to Applicant because he is not seeking anything more than opposition research on a political opponent. The Magistrate Judge clearly erred in granting the application for discovery and concluding that Chicago State University must respond to the document and deposition subpoenas

He urged the court to set aside the conclusion of the magistrate judge and reverse his order “because the information sought cannot be used and therefore is not “for use” in the foreign proceedings.

Atiku had, in his application, argued that among other things, a “second Chicago State University diploma has since emerged (dated June 27, 1979) that bears the name “Bola Ahmed Tinubu” but also presents with a different font, punctuation, seal, and signatures, than the June 22, 1979 diploma, among other alleged discrepancies.”

Atiku told the US that he wanted to authenticate these documents whether a “Chicago State University diploma in the name of Bola Ahmed Tinubu dated June 22, 1979, that was submitted to the INEC before the Nigerian presidential election in February 2023 is genuine or was forged.”

Atiku added that “under Nigerian law, the submission of a fraudulent document to the INEC would have disqualified President Tinubu from participating in the election.”

When Atiku filed his application in the US district court on 2 August, his petition challenging the presidential election was pending before the Nigerian Presidential Election Petition Tribunal. Therefore, Atiku said his application in the US court was to obtain discoveries that would support his petitions in the Nigerian court of appeal.

Court documents show that a day after Atiku’s application was filed, President Tinubu filed a motion to join in the suit. The judge granted the motion to intervene on 7 August.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

NDLEA arrests South African golfer, Kenyan chef over 50kg cannabis shipment

Published

on

By

Operatives of the National Drug Law Enforcement Agency have arrested a 37-year-old South African professional golfer, Grobler Henlo, and a 25-year-old Kenyan chef, Abubakar Njambi, over an alleged attempt to smuggle 50.40kg of a potent cannabis strain known as Loud into Nigeria.

This was disclosed in a statement issued on Sunday by NDLEA spokesperson, Femi Babafemi.

According to Babafemi, the suspects were arrested at the Murtala Muhammed International Airport, Ikeja, Lagos, in October.

The agency said Henlo arrived in Lagos from South Africa aboard a South African Airways flight on October 11 and was intercepted at the Terminal 2 arrival hall.

A search of two travelling boxes in his possession reportedly led to the recovery of 46 parcels of Loud weighing 50.40kg.

The NDLEA said investigations revealed that although the boxes were with Henlo, they bore the luggage tags of Njambi, who had collected two other boxes bearing his tags from the airport conveyor belt and left.

“The swap of luggage tags was a deliberate ploy by the syndicate to frustrate the identification of ownership, so that each courier could deny the boxes bearing his or her name if intercepted.

“During preliminary interview, the golfer, who travelled in business class while his accomplice flew economy, said he was recruited by a South African associate identified as Shanel, who linked him with other members of the syndicate he never met in person.

See also  ECOWAS sanctions: Nigeria cuts power supply to Niger Republic over coup

“He said a driver picked him up from his home in South Africa, handed him four travelling boxes and took him to the airport, where he was instructed to meet the Kenyan lady and swap luggage tags with her. He claimed he was promised 5,000 South African rand upon successful delivery,” the statement read.

It added, “Further examination revealed that tracking devices had been installed on the traveling boxes as well as on his mobile phone, a feature also found in the bags abandoned by the American basketballer a month later, which shows how closely the cartels monitor their couriers and consignments.

“The passport biodata page of Abubakar Faiza Njambi, recovered from the golfer’s phone, was profiled and placed on the NDLEA watchlist, leading to her arrest at the departure boarding gate of the Lagos airport on Thursday 15th October 2026 as she attempted to board a South African Airways flight to return to Kenya.

“The 25-year-old private chef told NDLEA operatives she was recruited by a man adding that a friend in Kenya, persuaded her to accept the offer of US$8,000 upon successful delivery of the consignment.

“She said she left Kenya for South Africa on 4th October, stayed in a hotel for about a week, and met the golfer at the airport in South Africa on 11th October, where he handed her two of the four boxes before they checked them in under their respective luggage tags.

See also  PROFILE: New Chief Of Army Staff, Abiodun Lagbaja

“She claimed that on arrival in Lagos, she collected the two boxes bearing the golfer’s tags, before a driver took her to a hotel in the Lekki area of Lagos.

“The claim tag of the two boxes bearing her name, which she abandoned at the airport, was recovered from her hand luggage, while both suspects identified each other during an identification parade.”

In a separate operation at the Lagos airport, NDLEA operatives on November 13 intercepted a consolidated consignment from the United Kingdom aboard an Allied Air flight.

The agency said the shipment contained 10 parcels of synthetic cannabinoids weighing 10.10kg, 27 packs of marshmallow weighing 318.80kg and precursor chemicals weighing a combined 34.55kg.

A freight agent, Sobowale Oladayo, was arrested when he presented himself to clear the consignment.

The consignee, identified as Kareem Issa, 35, also known as Ola, was arrested the following day when he arrived to collect the shipment at a logistics company’s premises in a grey Lexus 460 SUV.

The agency said Issa, a plumber who lives on Lagos Island, allegedly posed as a senior security official and routinely used a siren fitted to his vehicle when visiting the logistics company to collect consignments.

In Kaduna State, operatives arrested two men, Lawali Muhammad, 35, and Aliyu Mohammed, 30, in connection with 160 pieces of explosives intercepted along the Abuja-Kaduna Expressway at Jere on November 17. The intended recipient, Mohammed, was arrested in a follow-up operation in Gusau, Zamfara State, the agency said.

See also  Omokri insists Obi funded Rufai Oseni's father's funeral

Two other suspects were arrested along the same route with 6,900 tablets of tramadol, 20,000 tablets of diazepam and 25,000 tablets of Exol-5.

NDLEA operatives also recovered 627,500 capsules of tramadol weighing 21.50kg from a Hummer bus along the Zaria-Kano Expressway. The driver reportedly abandoned the vehicle and fled.

In Ogun State, a woman, Esther Ogundipe, was arrested on November 19 during a raid on a suspected drug joint at Eleweran, Abeokuta, with two locally made firearms and five live cartridges.

Two other women were arrested in Ilaro on November 17 with 7.4g of cocaine, 638g of cannabis and 5.9g of methamphetamine.

In Osun State, a 43-year-old man, Francis Oduke, was arrested along the Ikire-Ibadan Expressway with 359 bags of skunk weighing 4,627.7kg, allegedly concealed beneath a load of granite in a truck.

In neighbouring Ondo State, operatives intercepted a truck carrying 93 bags of cannabis weighing 1,045kg and heading to Kano State. The seizure was made along the Zango-Ado Expressway, Akure, on November 16.

Four suspects, Adamu Yerima, 19; Mohammed Mohammed, 19; Nura Mohammed, 25; and Usman Mohammed, were arrested in connection with the seizure.

Continue Reading

News

Fountain Of Life Church holds Sunday service amid high security presence

Published

on

By


There was a huge outpouring excitement as members of the Fountain of Life Church came enmasse for Sunday service amit very tight security, with several police vehicles seen parked outside of the church premises in Ilupeju, Lagos.

There have been reports suggesting that the church has been sealed by the police, but reports on the ground show on Sunday that the church has not been sealed.

According to TVC News, security agents claimed they merely on hand to ensure peace and order are maintained.
 

However, journalists were not allowed to film with the conventional camera inside the church.

See also  Military leaders didn’t want Tinubu as Lagos governor - Marwa
Continue Reading

News

Good morning! Nigerian Newspapers Headlines: 2027: Tinubu in Ibadan, vows rapid industrialisation

Published

on

By


1. It was very much unlike the All Progressives Congress (APC) previous presidential campaign rallies in Kaduna, Uyo, Port Harcourt, Enugu, Jos, Birnin Kebbi.

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu had called for a low key stump, and a low key rally it turned out to be, all in memory of the victims of the Friday boat tragedy in Bayelsa State.

At least 24 persons, including children, were confirmed dead in the accident.

2. Opposition parties in some states have expressed outrage over the widespread destruction of their campaign billboards, alleging deliberate attempts to stifle their political activities ahead of the 2027 general elections. The parties, in separate interviews with Sunday PUNCH, also lamented the imposition of exorbitant campaign fees, denial of access to public facilities for political rallies and restrictions on the erection of billboards



3. The Senior Pastor of the Fountain of Life Church, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya, has dragged his sister and others before a Federal High Court in Lagos, challenging his purported removal from office and the decision taken by some members of the church’s Board of Trustees. Odukoya, alongside the Incorporated Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church, instituted the action against eight defendants, including Pastor Tolu Odukoya, Mr Biodun Balogun, Mr Biodun Awosika, Pastor Rotimi Okpaise, Pastor Tobi Enuha, Pastor Gbenga Onabanjo, Pastor Fred Ohiani and Pastor Akin Osinbajo.

See also  Good morning! Here Are Some Major News Headlines In The Newspapers Today: Presidency to Obasanjo: You’re Not Ideal Leader to Emulate

4. The North East Unity Forum (NUF) has urged former Vice President Atiku Abubakar to abandon his 2027 presidential ambition and retire from active  politics, arguing that Nigeria needs younger and more dynamic leaders. The Forum said Atiku, who is approaching 80, lacks the physical vitality, fresh ideas and moral standing required to lead the country in an increasingly complex and fast-changing world.

5. Commercial and other activities were temporarily suspended as members and non-members of the All Progressives Congress (APC) from the South-West geopolitical zone turned out in large numbers at the zonal campaign rally of the party at the ancient Mapo Hall in Ibadan South-East Local Government Area on Saturday. All the link roads to the venue of the event were closed to traffic, while the popular Oja’ba, Oritamerin and Mapo markets were shut down for the duration of the event.

6. The House of Representatives is considering a bill seeking to make the denial of conjugal rights for at least three months an additional ground for divorce in the country. The proposed amendment to the Matrimonial Causes Act, 2004, also seeks to recognise threats or infliction of grievous bodily harm, as well as emotional and psychological trauma, as grounds for seeking the dissolution of a marriage.

See also  Sit-at-home: Empty streets, markets as residents comply with IPOB’s order in south-east

7. Bayelsa State Governor, Senator Douye Diri, has ordered an investigation into Friday’s boat mishap in Southern Ijaw Local Government Area of the state following the recovery of 23 bodies, while 24 survivors have been rescued. The governor also directed that anyone found culpable in the incident be prosecuted, saying preliminary findings indicated that the boat was overloaded, had no passenger manifest and that most of those on board were not wearing life jackets.

8. Nigeria’s Minister of Youth Development, Ayodele Olawande, has married his partner, Stella Ifeoluwa Elegbe, in a colourful ceremony in Akure, Ondo State. The white wedding, held on Saturday at the Christ Apostolic Church, Revival Centre, Akure, attracted family members, friends,  political associates and top government officials.

9. President of the Senate, Godswill Akpabio, has warned politicians against turning the 2027 general elections into a do-or-die contest, urging political leaders to rein in their supporters and avoid actions capable of triggering tension ahead of the polls. Akpabio gave the warning while reaffirming the Federal Government’s commitment to conducting free, fair and credible elections, amid growing political activities ahead of the 2027 general elections.

See also  Wife sets husband ablaze over secret child in Osun

10. The leadership dispute at the Fountain of Life Church, Lagos, following the death of its founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, has brought a difficult question facing many founder-led churches into public focus: Who takes charge when the person around whom a ministry was built is no longer there?

Continue Reading

Trending News